The Scorecard by Iowa Investor — Issue No. 5
One company. One framework. One lesson.
This week: Alphabet (GOOGL), the re-grade
Score: 63/100 — SOLID (needs a bigger discount). Was 68.
Here's the trap this week: a stock drops 12% in a day, and everybody's first thought is "it's on sale." Alphabet closed last Thursday, Oct. 29, at $283.82, down 12.6%, after its third-quarter report. Cheaper stock. So the score goes up, right? It went down.
A note before the scorecard: this is a re-grade, not a new pick. In Issue No. 2, Alphabet scored 68/100, and I promised to re-score it when the real Q3 numbers landed. They landed on Oct. 28 (earnings release) and Oct. 29 (the full quarterly report, the 10-Q). The framework doesn't care which way the stock moved. It cares what the business did. Same four pillars, same rules, new numbers.
P.S. from last week: Apple reported Monday. Nothing in the quarter changes the verdict: 77/100 stands.
Moat: 25/30 (was 24, up 1). The moat got a second wall. Google Cloud revenue roughly doubled from a year ago, to $30.7 billion for the quarter, and it earned $11.1 billion of operating profit on it, about a 36% margin. That's not a side business anymore. Cloud's contracted backlog, work customers have already signed up for, is now $560.8 billion, and Alphabet expects to recognize about 55% of its total backlog within 24 months. Customers don't sign half-trillion-dollar commitments with a company they plan to leave.
The honest part: the old wall is still taking hits. Search and other revenue grew 12% to $63.4 billion, solid, but it missed Wall Street's estimates again. YouTube ads grew 9%, slower than the 13% we scored last time. And the search monopoly appeals are still pending in court. Wide moat, now with two walls instead of one. Twenty-five.
Management: 10/20 (was 12, down 2). Last time I wrote that Alphabet "stopped buying its own shares and started selling them." The 10-Q says it kept going. Buybacks through nine months: $0. Shares sold to the public in Q3 through an "at-the-market" program, meaning stock sold bit by bit into the market: $12.4 billion, about 36 million shares, with $27.6 billion more still available to sell. New debt issued this year: $85.2 billion, including $28.7 billion of notes in Q3 alone. The diluted share count rose to 12.37 billion from 12.20 billion a year ago, so every owner's slice got a little smaller.
And management says spending will "increase significantly" again in 2027. Maybe the AI build-out earns great returns. Cloud's margins are early evidence that it might. But right now the returns are promised, not proven, and the bill is being paid with your shares and borrowed money. Talented operators. Expensive allocators. Ten.
Financial Health: 17/25 (was 20, down 3). Free cash flow is the cash left after running the business and paying for new equipment. Last time I flagged one negative quarter, Q2's –$5.9 billion, as a first. Q3 made it two in a row: $42.3 billion of operating cash flow, $51.4 billion of capital spending, –$9.1 billion of free cash flow. Trailing twelve-month free cash flow is down to $19.7 billion.
The balance sheet is changing shape fast. Long-term debt went from $46.5 billion in December to $125.1 billion in September. Quarterly interest expense went from $143 million to $967 million, almost 7 times higher. Property and equipment grew from $246.6 billion to $372.8 billion in nine months. Cash and securities are still $265.1 billion, but about $75.2 billion of that is SpaceX stock it can't freely sell. And the business itself is still excellent: revenue up 25% to $127.6 billion, a 31.8% operating margin. A fortress that's taking out a mortgage to build the next wing. Seventeen.
Valuation: 11/25 (was 12, down 1). Lean in, because this is the whole issue. Tuesday's close: $280.03. Reported earnings were $2.12 a share for the quarter, but that includes an $8.7 billion paper loss on stakes in other companies, mostly SpaceX, worth about –$0.55 a share. Strip it out and core earnings were about $2.67. Run that rate for a full year (about $10.68) and you're paying roughly 26 times core earnings. When we first scored Alphabet, it was about 24 times. The stock is cheaper than it was before earnings. On core earnings, it's more expensive than when we first scored it.
Free cash tells the same story, louder. At about $3.5 trillion in market value and $19.7 billion of trailing free cash flow, you're paying roughly 176 times free cash flow. Last time it was about 79 times. For every $100 you invest, the business currently throws off about 57 cents of free cash. The price fell. The cash fell faster.
Why 11 and not single digits? Because revenue is growing 25%, Cloud is printing real profit, and if that spending pays off, today's cash flow is the low point, not the normal. Full price for a great business mid-build. Not a bargain. Eleven.
Red-flag check: 0 of 5. Accounting manipulation: no. Management integrity issues: no. Structural industry decline: no. Debt distress: no, though debt nearly tripled this year, so it's the one to watch. Excessive customer concentration: no. No cap applies.
Verdict: 63/100 — SOLID. Needs a bigger discount. Look at the board: Apple 77, Costco 75, Deere 70, Alphabet 63, down from 68. It's still SOLID (the 60 to 79 band), but now it sits at the bottom of the range. This isn't a sell call, and it isn't a buy call. Moat up one. Management, balance sheet and price all down. The stock dropped 12.6% in a day, and the framework says it still isn't cheap enough.
The system lesson: "A falling price isn't the same as a margin of safety." A margin of safety is a cushion between the price you pay and what the business is really worth, so you can be wrong and still be okay. A price drop only creates that cushion if the value held still. This quarter, Alphabet's value didn't hold still: more shares, more debt, less free cash, bigger promises. When price and value fall together, there's no new cushion. The stock just got cheaper. Before you call anything "on sale," ask: cheaper than what it's worth, or just cheaper than last week?
Disclosure: The author's company holds shares of and options on Alphabet (GOOGL). The author's company holds shares of and options on SpaceX (SPCX). The author's company owns shares of Apple (AAPL).
The Iowa Investor is education, not financial advice. Every score reflects the framework's judgment, not a recommendation. Do your own work.
The fine print: The Scorecard is published by Iowa Investor (KEOWA, LLC) for educational purposes only. Nothing in this newsletter is personalized investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Scores are opinion, built from public information believed reliable but not guaranteed, and are not predictions of future results. The author may hold positions in companies mentioned here; any position in the featured company is disclosed in each issue. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Do your own research or consult a licensed advisor before making investment decisions.
Price data as of Nov 3, 2026 close; fundamentals through Q3 2026 (earnings release Oct 28, 2026; Form 10-Q filed Oct 29, 2026). Price $280.03; valuation anchors recomputed from that close (core P/E on annualized Q3 core EPS of ~$2.67, excluding the $8.7B equity-securities loss; price-to-FCF on TTM FCF of $19.7B and 12.37B diluted shares). The one-day drop cited above is the Oct 28 close of $324.89 to the Oct 29 close of $283.82 (-12.6%). Re-grade of Issue No. 2 (68/100, data as of Sep 26, 2026). Score: Moat 25, Management 10, Financial Health 17, Valuation 11 — 63/100 SOLID.
