The Scorecard by Iowa Investor — Issue No. 6
One company. One framework. One lesson.
This week: Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-B)
Score: 79/100 — SOLID.
Berkshire is the Omaha neighbor everybody seems to know. But knowing the name isn't the same as knowing the price.
Inside are insurance businesses, BNSF's railroad, utilities, manufacturers, retailers and a big investment portfolio. Berkshire reported its third quarter on Saturday, so this week's score uses fresh numbers. The useful question isn't "Would I trust the famous name?" It's "What am I paying for the earnings, and what could go wrong?" Same four pillars. No extra points for fame.
The quarter in one breath. Operating earnings, Berkshire's measure that leaves out investment gains and losses, were $12.7 billion, down about 6% from a year ago. Most of that dip came from currency swings on Berkshire's foreign-currency debt. Without that swing, the businesses earned about the same as last year. The railroad, the utilities and the manufacturing and retail businesses all earned more. Insurance earned less. Berkshire also bought back about $9.6 billion of its own stock in the quarter.
Moat: 27/30. You can't build another BNSF rail network over a long weekend. Rights-of-way, tracks and connections take enormous money and time. BNSF's after-tax earnings rose 19% in the quarter on higher volumes and better efficiency. Utilities have hard-to-copy infrastructure, too, though regulators have a say in what they can earn. Berkshire Hathaway Energy earned 8% more.
Insurance adds another advantage: scale and money to invest while claims are waiting to be paid. Berkshire held about $178.5 billion of insurance float at the end of September. Float is that pool of funds held ahead of claims. It isn't a gift, and it isn't shareholder equity.
This quarter showed the catch. Underwriting profit fell 43%. GEICO kept about 8.6 cents of every premium dollar as underwriting profit, down from about 15.7 cents a year ago. That's still profitable, and there were no big catastrophe losses, but insurance stays competitive. Wide moat, not an invisible force field. Twenty-seven.
Management: 17/20. Greg Abel is the CEO now. Warren Buffett's record doesn't automatically become Abel's future record.
Berkshire bought back about $9.6 billion of stock in the third quarter and $14.4 billion so far this year. Its rule is to buy only below intrinsic value, conservatively determined. By our math from its monthly table, it paid about $503 per Class B share on average. The company also finished buying homebuilder Taylor Morrison in July for about $6.8 billion, after buying OxyChem in January for about $9.4 billion.
That's a management team putting real money to work under a sensible rule: about $9.6 billion of buybacks at roughly $503 a share, and a $6.8 billion acquisition closed. That earns a point this quarter. It doesn't earn full marks, because a busy quarter isn't a long track record, and whether Taylor Morrison and OxyChem earn good returns will take years to show. Seventeen.
Financial Health: 23/25. At September 30, the insurance and other businesses held $352.3 billion in cash and Treasury bills after subtracting bills bought but not yet paid for. That's down a bit from June because Berkshire paid for Taylor Morrison and those buybacks. Shareholders' equity rose to $761.4 billion.
But "big cash pile" does not mean "no obligations." Consolidated borrowings were about $130.8 billion, including $85.0 billion in the railroad, utilities and energy businesses. Berkshire doesn't guarantee BNSF's or Berkshire Hathaway Energy's debt, but those operations still have to pay their bills. Insurance claims are real obligations, too.
PacifiCorp's wildfire cases belong on the page. PacifiCorp has paid about $2.3 billion in settlements so far, and its estimated unpaid amount fell to $566 million. The company still says more material losses are reasonably possible and can't estimate how much. Excellent resources, not immunity. Twenty-three.
Valuation: 12/25. Tuesday's close (Nov 10): $583.62. Using Berkshire's latest share count across both share classes gives an equity value of about $1.24 trillion.
Here's where the headline can fool you. Over the last four quarters, the accounting bottom line puts the multiple near 16 times. But those earnings include investment gains, $9.4 billion of them in the third quarter alone.
Operating earnings over the last four quarters were $47.2 billion. At Tuesday's close (Nov 10), that's about 26.3 times. You're also paying about 1.63 times book value, the accounting value of shareholders' equity. The earnings multiple is a little richer than it was before the report; price-to-book is almost the same.
One more thing to watch: Berkshire's insurance investment income fell 14% in the quarter because short-term interest rates are lower. When you hold hundreds of billions in Treasury bills, lower rates mean less income.
And a fun comparison, not a valuation: Tuesday's close (Nov 10) is about 16% above what Berkshire itself paid, on average, for its own shares last quarter.
Why twelve? Quality and financial flexibility deserve something. A clear bargain deserves more evidence. Twelve.
Red-flag check: 0 of 5 framework triggers identified.
Accounting manipulation: none identified.
Management integrity issues: none identified in reviewed materials.
Structural industry decline: none identified across the group.
Debt distress: none identified.
Excessive customer concentration: none identified at group level.
No cap applies. This is a limited public-source screen, not an audit. PacifiCorp litigation, catastrophe losses, falling interest income, investment concentration and leadership execution remain important risks.
Verdict: 79/100 — SOLID. Excellent resources; price still matters. Moat 27, Management 17, Financial Health 23, Valuation 12. The third quarter mostly confirmed the picture, and management's capital allocation earned one extra point. The railroad and the operating businesses got stronger. Insurance and interest income got weaker. The stock is a little higher than it was last week. That puts Berkshire just above Apple's 77 in this series, ahead of Costco at about 75, Deere at 70 and Alphabet's latest 63. The difference comes from the business and the balance sheet, not a famous last name. It is not a buy call or a sell call. It is the framework's judgment at a dated price.
The system lesson: "A cash pile is not a discount." Picture an insurer collecting a premium today and paying a claim later. The money in between can earn a return. But some of that money has a future job: paying the claim.
Now picture subtracting all of Berkshire's cash from its share price and calling what remains a cheap business. If you still count all the interest that cash earns in the profit figure, you've counted the benefit twice. If you forget claims and operating needs, you've treated committed money as spare money. And as this quarter showed, the income on that cash shrinks when rates fall. A sensible valuation keeps the assets, the earnings and the obligations together. A strong balance sheet can make a business safer without making its stock a bargain.
Disclosure: The author owns options on Berkshire Hathaway Class B (BRK-B) and may buy shares.
The Iowa Investor is education, not financial advice. Every score reflects the framework's judgment, not a recommendation. Do your own work.
The fine print: The Scorecard is published by Iowa Investor (KEOWA, LLC) for educational purposes only. Nothing in this newsletter is personalized investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Scores are opinion, built from public information believed reliable but not guaranteed, and are not predictions of future results. The author may hold positions in companies mentioned here; any position in the featured company is disclosed in each issue. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Do your own research or consult a licensed advisor before making investment decisions.
Data note:
Price: BRK-B regular-session close on Tue Nov 10, 2026: $583.62 (StockAnalysis / S&P Global history; Nasdaq's 4:00 PM ET close field was $583.61). Yahoo Finance historical listed $583.34. Nasdaq's historical table had not posted Nov 10 at the time of this pull.
Results: Q3 and first nine months through Sep 30, 2026, released Nov 7, 2026.
Operating earnings: Q3 $12.705B vs $13.485B. Trailing four quarters $47.234B = FY2025 $44.486B − 9M 2025 $34.286B + 9M 2026 $37.034B.
Equity value: about $1.240T, using Oct 28, 2026 shares of 480,476 A + 1,403,805,594 B (2,124,519,594 B equivalents).
Multiples: about 26.3× trailing operating earnings and 1.63× book value of $357.73 per B equivalent ($761.368B ÷ 2,128.35M B equivalents at Sep 30).
GEICO: underwriting margin is 100% minus the combined ratio (91.4% vs 84.3%).
Average buyback price: about $503 per B equivalent, computed from Berkshire's Q3 monthly repurchase table.
See scorecard-q3.md for the full ledger and page references.
Primary sources: Q3 release · Q3 10-Q · FY2025 release · Price history (StockAnalysis) · Price history (Yahoo).
